Feb 10, 2012

စစ္တပ္သည္အစိုးရမဟုတ္ပါ

၁။       အစိုးရနဲ႕တပ္မေတာ္ကို ခြဲျခားၿပီးေျပာပါ။

၂။       တပ္မေတာ္ဟာ အစိုးရရဲ႕ မူ၀ါဒအတိုင္း လုပ္ရမွာပါ။ ဗိုလ္ခ်ဳပ္ေတြက အစိုးရတက္လုပ္ႏိုင္လို႔                    အတိုက္အခံကိုႏွိမ္နင္းခိုင္းရင္ ႏွိမ္နင္းမွာပဲျဖစ္သလို N L Dက အစိုးရျဖစ္လာၿပီး သူတို႔နဲ႕အတိုက္ အခံကို ႏွိမ္နင္းဖို႔ တပ္ကိုအသံုးခ်လည္း တပ္ကေတာ့ ခိုင္းတဲ့အတိုင္း လုပ္ရမွာပါပဲ။

၃။       စစ္တပ္ကိုး ။ အထက္အမိန႔္ နာခံတတ္ေအာင္ ေလ့က်င့္ထားတာပါ။ အမိန္႔မနာခံဘဲဲနဲ႕လဲ စစ္တိုက္ လို႔ မရပါ။ ေရွ႕တန္းမွာ ဒီလမ္းက ဒီေတာင္ကုန္းကို တက္သိမ္းဆို မိုင္း႐ွိ႐ွိ ၊ ေျငာင့္ေထာင္ေထာင္ စက္ေသနတ္ ဘယ္ႏွစ္လက္နဲ႔ပစ္ပစ္  တက္ရမွာပါ။ ေနာက္ေန႔မွွတိုက္ပါရေစ ၊ တျခားလမ္းကသြား ပါရေစ လုပ္လို႔မရပါ။ စစ္သားရဲ႕ေတြးေခၚပံုကိုက အရပ္သားနဲ႕မတူပါ ။ မတူေအာင္လည္း ေလ့က်င့္ထားတာပါ။ စစ္သားကို စစ္တရား႐ံုးနဲ႔ပဲ တရားစီရင္ခြင့္ရွိတာဟာ စစ္သားရဲ႕စဥ္းစားပံုဟာ အရပ္သားနဲ႔မတူလို႔ပါ။

၄။       စစ္တပ္ကို လက္ကိုင္ဒုတ္ စစ္တပ္မျဖစ္ေစခ်င္ရင္ စနစ္ကို ခိုင္မာေအာင္လုပ္ပါ။ ဘယ္သူတက္ တက္ စစ္တပ္ကို အသံုးခ်လို႔မရေအာင္ ဖြဲ႔စည္းပံုအေျခခံဥပေဒကို ဆြဲထားပါ။ အေမရိကန္ႏိုင္ငံသ မိုင္းမွာ ႏိုင္ငံေရးသမားေတြ ဖြဲ႔စည္းပံုအေျခခံဥပေဒကို ေရပက္မ၀င္ေအာင္ ဆြဲခဲ့လို႔ စစ္တပ္က အာဏာသိမ္းတာ တစ္ခါမွမရွိပါ။ တပ္မေတာ္ကလည္း အသံုးခ်ခံခ်င္လွတယ္ေတာ့ မရွိပါ။ ဒါေပမယ့္ အစိုးရကို ပုန္ကန္တဲ့တပ္မေတာ္ ပိုၿပီးမျဖစ္လိုပါ။ စစ္တပ္မ်က္စိကၾကည့္လွ်င္ အထက္ အမိန္႔မနာခံတဲ့ တပ္မေတာ္္ဟာ အႏၱရာယ္အႀကီးဆံုးပါ။ အေမရိကန္စစ္ကားထဲမွာ တပ္ခြဲမွဴးက သူ႔ရဲေဘာ္ကို စစ္ေျမျပင္မွာ ေျပာတဲ့အတိုင္း ေျပာရရင္  “ ငါတို႔က ဒီမိုကေရစီကို ကာကြယ္ဖို႔ ဒီေနရာကိုေရာက္ေနတာ - - - က်င့္သံုးဖို႔မဟုတ္ပါ ” တဲ့ ။

၅။       ဗိုလ္ခ်ဳပ္ေတြ မသမာမႈလုပ္ခြင့္ရတာ ဗိုလ္ခ်ဳပ္ရာထူးေၾကာင့္မဟုတ္ပါ။ အာဏာသိမ္းၿပီး နိုင္ငံေရး ရာထူးေတြ ယူခြင့္ရသြားလို႔ပါ။ ႏိုင္ငံေရးသမားမ်ားအခ်င္းခ်င္း ညီညြတ္လွ်င္ အာဏာသိမ္းလို႔မရပါ။ ဘယ္တပ္မေတာ္မွလည္း ႏိုင္ငံေရးပေယာဂမပါဘဲ အေခ်ာင္နာမည္ပ်က္ခံၿပီး အာဏာသိမ္းလိုမယ္ မဟုတ္ပါ။


၆။       စစ္တပ္ကိုလဲ သိပ္ျပည့္စံုေနတယ္မထင္ပါနဲ႔ ။ ကၽြန္ေတာ္ တပ္မေတာ္ကအၿငိမ္းစားယူတဲ့အထိ စစ္တိုက္ရမယ့္ေနရာကို ရဟတ္ယာဥ္နဲ႔ တစ္ခါမွ အပို႔မခံရဖူးပါ။ စစ္သားေတြ ဒဏ္ရာရရင္ အိပ္ယာခင္းေစာင္ၾကားကို ၀ါးလုံးနဲ႔လွ်ိဳ ပုခက္လုပ္ၿပီး ႏွစ္ရက္သံုးရက္ လူနဲ႔ထမ္းၿပီး သယ္ရတာပါ။ ရိကၡာ (၅)ရက္စာဆို (၁၀)ရက္စာ စားရတာပါ။ စစ္ဆင္ေရး (၃)လေလာက္ဆို ရဲေဘာ္ေတြ၀တ္စံု ဟာ ခ်ဳပ္ရာ၊ဖာရာ အထပ္ထပ္ ဖိနပ္ကလည္း ညွပ္ဖိနပ္ျဖစ္ေနပါၿပီ။ တပ္ၾကပ္ႀကီးကို မေျပာရေကာင္းလားလို႔ သြားမဆူပါနဲ႔ ။သူ႔မွာလည္း အားလံုးေပါင္းမွ ရဲေဘာ္ေတြထက္ ၀တ္စံုတစ္စံု ေလာက္သာ ပိုခ်မ္းသာတာပါ။ စစ္ေၾကာင္း႐ံုးကို ၾကည့္လိုက္ပါဦး။ စစ္ေၾကာင္းမွဴးေဘာင္းဘီလည္း ဖင္အဖာနဲ႔ပါပဲ။ စစ္သည္တစ္ေယာက္ဟာ ေသနတ္၊ ရိကၡာ ၊ က်ည္ဆံ၊ ခ်ပ္၀တ္တန္ဆာနဲ႔ဆို ေပါင္(၄၀)ေလာက္ရွိေနပါၿပီ။ စစ္ေၾကာင္းအဆင့္ဆို ပြိဳင့္ဖိုက္ ၊ ၈၁ မမစိန္ေျပာင္း၊ ပြိဳင့္ဖိုက္ က်ည္ဆံ (၁၀၀၀)ပံုး တစ္ပံုးဟာ တုိက္ပြဲျဖစ္လွ်င္ (၅)မိနစ္ေလာက္ပဲ ပစ္လို႔ရပါတယ္။ ဗ်ဴဟာအဆင့္မွာ လာပါၿပီ ၁၂၀ မမစိန္ေျပာင္းႀကီး ဗံုးသီးတစ္လံုးက ေပါင္ (၃၀)ေလာက္ ၊စက္႐ံုကထုတ္တဲ့ဗူးကိုဖြင့္ ၿပီး ထမ္းပိုးနဲ႔ ေရွ႕ေနာက္ႀကိဳးခ်ည္ ရဲေဘာ္တစ္ေယာက္ကို ထမ္းပိုးတစ္လက္နဲ႔ မသိလွ်င္ ကန္စြန္းဥတြဲေလးေတြက်လို႔ ။ ေပၚတာဆြဲတာကို ကၽြန္ေတာ္တို႔လည္းမႀကိဳက္ပါ ဒါေပမဲ့ ရဲေဘာ္ပဲထမ္းဆို ရဲေဘာ္တစ္ေယာက္ကို ေပါင္(၇၀)ေလာက္ ရွိေနပါၿပီ။ စစ္ေၾကာင္းက တစ္ရက္လံုးမွ (၅)မိုင္ေတာင္ ခရီးမေပါက္ခ်င္. . . ဒဏ္ရာရလူနာသာပါလွ်င္ စဥ္းစားၾကည့္ပါေတာ့ ေပၚတာဆြဲလွ်င္လည္း အေရးယူခံရ၊ မဆြဲဘဲ ကိုယ္တိုင္ထမ္းရေတာ့လဲ တိုက္ပြဲျဖစ္တဲ့အခါ ရန္သူက လက္သီးနဲ႔ဆင္းထိုးလွ်င္ေတာင္ ခံရေတာ့မေလာက္ အေလးအပင္ေတြနဲ႔ သူမ်ားနိုင္ငံ တပ္မေတာ္ေတြလည္း ၾကည့္ၾကည့္ၾကပါ။ စစ္သားဟာ ၀န္တင္ႏြားမဟုတ္ပါ။

၇။       လူ႔အခြင့္အေရးဆိုလို႔ ေျပာရဦးမယ္။ ခင္ဗ်ားတု႔ိထဲက ဘယ္ႏွစ္ေယာက္ ေ႐ွ႕တန္းေရာက္ဖူးပါသလဲ။ ေတာထဲကို မေရာက္ဖူးဘဲနဲ႕ေတာ့ ေတာရဲ႕အေၾကာင္းကို မသိႏိုင္ပါ။ ေတာမွာ ရဲစခန္းမရွိပါ၊ တရား႐ံုးမရွိပါ ။ေတာထဲမွာရွိတာ ေတာရဲ႕ဥပေဒပါ။ အင္အားႀကီးတဲ့လူူက အင္အားနည္းတဲ့လူကို ေခ်မႈန္းတာ နားေထာင္လို႔မေကာင္းပါ။ မေထာက္ခံပါ ဒါေပမယ့္ ကိုယ္ရွင္သန္ႏိုင္ဖို႔ ကိုယ့္တပ္ဖြဲ႕ရွင္သန္ႏိုင္ဖို႔ ရုန္းကန္ရာမွာ နည္းလမ္းေရြးခ်ယ္ခြင့္မရွိေတာ့တဲ့ အေျခအေနေတြ အမ်ားႀကီး ႀကံဳေတြ႔ရႏိုင္တာ။ တစ္ဦးတစ္ေလကေတာ့ ခင္ဗ်ားတို႔ ေျပာေျပာေနတဲ့ လူသားခ်င္းစာနာမႈအတြက္ သူ႔အသက္ကို စေတးခ်င္စေတးမွာပါ။ ဒါေပမယ့္ လူတိုင္းေတာ့မဟုတ္ပါ။ ခင္ဗ်ားတို႔ထဲမွာ ရန္သူကႏွိပ္စက္ၿပီး ဓားနဲ႔လွီးသတ္သြားတဲ့ ကိုယ့္ရဲေဘာ္ အေလာင္းကို ဘယ္သူျမင္ဖူးပါသလဲ ။ ရြာအ၀င္လယ္ကြင္းထဲက ေကာက္စိုက္ဟန္ေဆာင္္ေနတဲ့ ရြာသားထင္ရတဲ့သူက ေသနတ္နဲ႕ ေတ့ပစ္တာကို ဘယ္သူခံဖူးပါသလဲ။ ရြာထဲက (၅၇)နဲ႕ ေထာင္းထေမာင္းေၾကေအာင္ ပစ္ခံရလို႔ ကိုယ့္ေရွ႕မွာပဲ ကိုယ့္ရဲေဘာ္ေတြ က်ဆံုးကုန္တဲ့ သူပုန္နဲ႕ရြာသား ခြဲမရတဲ့ တပ္ခြဲမွဴးဘ၀ကို ဘယ္သူကိုယ္ခ်င္းစာဖူးပါသလဲ။ ခင္ဗ်ားမွာ ဒုတိယနည္းလမ္း ေ႐ြးခ်ယ္ဖုိ႔မရွိခဲ့လွ်င္ ခင္ဗ်ားရြာထဲကို ျပန္ပစ္မလား ? ခင္ဗ်ားတပ္ခြဲ အေသခံမလား?

၈။       ႀကံ႕ဖြံ႔၊ႀကံ႕ဖြံ႔နဲ႕ ခင္ဗ်ားတို႔ ဆဲခ်င္ဆဲပါ ဒါေပမယ့္ စစ္တပ္နဲ႕ ႀကံ႕ဖြံ႕ ဘာမွမဆိုင္ပါ။ ႀကံ႕ုဖြံ႕ခုိင္းတာလုပ္ေနရတာ ႀကံ႕ဖြံ႕အစိုးရေနရာေရာက္ေနလို႔ပါ။ ရဲ ၊ မီးသတ္၊ ရ.ယ.က စြမ္းအား၊စည္ပင္ ၊ လ.၀.က၊ အခြန္၊ေဆာက္လုပ္ေရး ၊ပညာေရး ၊က ည န ၊ ေထြ/အုပ္၀န္ထမ္း အားလံုးလိုပဲ စစ္တပ္ကလည္း ၀န္ထမ္းပါ။ ခင္ဗ်ားတို႔ မေမ့ဖို႔က ခင္ဗ်ားတို႔မွျပည္သူမဟုတ္ပါ ၀န္ထမ္းေတြအားလံုးကလည္း တက္လာတဲ့အစိုးရခိုင္းတာ လုပ္ရတဲ့ျပည္သူေတြပါ။ ခင္ဗ်ားတို႔ ႏိုင္ငံေရးသမားအမ်ားစုလည္း (၂၂)ႏွစ္မွာ အႏွစ္(၂၀)ေလာက္က ပုဆိုးၿခံဳထဲက လက္သီးျပေနတာပါ။ ခုမွ ဘာညာနဲ႔ေတာ့ ၀န္ထမ္းမ်ားကို လာမေျပာေစလိုပါ။ အုပ္ခ်ဳပ္တဲ့သူေကာင္းဖို႔ဆိုတာ အားလံုးမွာတာ၀န္ရွိတာပါ။ ခင္ဗ်ားတို႔ အခုလို တစ္ဖက္သတ္ ကိုယ့္ကိုယ္ကို ပံုျပင္ထဲကသူရဲေကာင္းလို၊ မင္းသမီးေလးလိုလုပ္ က်န္တဲ့သူေတြကိုေတာ့ ပံုျပင္ထဲကစုန္းမႀကီးလို၊ မေကာင္းဆိုး၀ါးႀကီးလို လုပ္ေနပံုနဲ႕ေတာ့ ႏိုင္ငံကို ေကာင္းေအာင္၊ တိုးတက္ေအာင္ အုပ္ခ်ဴပ္ႏိုင္ဖို႔ေ၀းလို႔ (၂)ႏွစ္(၃)ႏွစ္ေလာက္ဆိုရင္ကို ကိုယ့္ပါတီကို ႏိုင္ေအာင္အုပ္ခ်ဳပ္ႏိုင္ဖို႔ မလြယ္ပါ။

(YE MOE-Facebook)
Print Friendly and PDF

19 ေယာက္ ေဆြးေႏြးခဲ့တယ္:

Anonymous said...

ႀကိဳက္တယ္ဗ်ာ ေရးသားခ်က္ေတြ .. အားေပးေနတယ္ဗ်ိဳးးးး ကြန္မန့္သာမေပးဖစ္တာပါ ဒီဆိုက္ကို ေန့တိုင္း ေရာက္တယ္။။။။

Anonymous said...

ႀကိဳက္တယ္ စစ္သားဆိုတာ ေခြးအလုပ္ေရာ ႏြားအလုပ္ေရာလုပ္ေနရတာ
ဒါေပမယ့္ ဒီမိုကေရစီလိုေျပာမယ္ တန္ရာတန္ေၾကး ဘာအခြင့္ေရးေတြမ်ား ေပးထားလို႕လဲ

တိမ္ၾကားမင္းေခါင္ said...

ခုလိုခြဲခြဲျခားျခားျမင္တတ္၇င္အေကာင္းဆံုးေပါ့ဗ်ာ။ျပည္သူေတြလဲသိတတ္ျမင္တတ္ပါေစ။စစ္တတ္ကိုမုန္းတယ္လို႕ေျပာေနတဲ့လူေတြလဲအျမင္ၾကည္လင္ၾကပါေစ။အကယ္လို႕မုန္းေနမယ္ဆုိရင္လဲ တပ္မေတာ္ဟာျပည္သူခ်စ္ဖို႕အတြက္ရွင္းျပမွာမဟုတ္ပါဘူး။လိုအပ္မွသာျပည္သူကုိအသက္နဲ႕လဲျပီးကာကြယ္သြားပါလိမ့္မယ္ဆိုတာကိုေတာ့သိေစခ်င္ပါတယ္။

Anonymous said...

I really appreciate the author.
I am Commission officer from Myanmar military and now I am studying in one of the West Europe Country. I don't want to say like that but most of the opposition people thought that the soldiers are very stupid, uneducated and have no Idea about Democracy. And they also have very good impression on the Western Country. Now you will know that I am studying higher education and I am not a stupid guy.
Before I came here, I was neutral and had no feeling on my organization. But, after more than five months in here, now I am very proud of myself as a soldier in Myanmar. Yes of course. It is because of the opposition people. I am going to explain it.
Whenever I am reading the news and using face book, most of the opposition people talked the soldiers like a dog. I am feeling very sorry and bad. We are human being and we also have the same feeling like you. Nothing more and nothing less. But we are taking responsibility for our country and people with a different point of view.
As you might know that every organization has the good guys and the bad guys, not only in the military but also in others. I do believe that all of opposition organization will be more or less the same with us. So why are you still blaming us?
We, the younger generation didn't do anything wrong but we are being treated like a dog and robber.
For instants, if something is going wrong in our country like the 8888 uprising, what the military should do? Do you think your lovely politicians can manage this event very well? They were already tested their ability in 1958 and 1988. They couldn't do anything in that period. They were just fighting and arguing with each other. That's all. Nothing more.
Now I am living in well developed Democratic country. To be honest, I like this system very much, no doubt. I really like the way they are living in here. I also don't want to hear about my country which is ruled by military junta.
But if someone is trying to manipulate our National solidarity and sovereignty, we will have no choice. If we do it again, we will be labeled as tyrant. WHATEVER YOU NAME US, WE WON'T CARE YOU ANYMORE. This is the way we are going to live in our whole life. Do you know what is the reason behind it?
The reason is very simple that WE ARE SOLDIERS.

Anonymous said...

Hard reality is the fact of life for soldiers but many occasions whether these hard reality is required we have to examine. Time is the best judge for all, I have been writing since 1998 debunking and shredding the claims of socalled DoAyay and blind quislings and democampers in internet.
But still, there definitely is something we, as a Tatmadaw, can do, to alleviate these hard reality of soldiers. Yes Tatmadaw is NOT government but it was a big part of government till very recently.
ordinaryman

Anonymous said...

Yes! Definitely. We, Tatmadaw is still a big part of the Government. It is very hard to accept it. That is one of the reasons , the opposition people have been blaming us. But sooner or latter we are going to step out gradually from political field.

Nowadays, most of the opposition people who have been living in Foreign countries, are trying to come back and do politics inside the country. Welcome back!!!! But there will become more and more players in the Game and I am afraid that they will be fighting and arguing again like 1958 and 1988.

For my subjective opinion, I think NLD would be the landslide winner in 2015 election. CHEERS!!!My suggestion is that after having power in your hand, please organize all the politicians to be unity (I know that you could have different Ideas but please try to find out the peaceful way to develop our country). And, I also know that Generals are still watching what the politician are doing. The only thing in their heads is that the STABILITY AND PEACE OF THE COUNTRY.If they believe in our lovely Politicians, they will never enter the complex game. From a politician point of view, it is very difficult to accept it. But it is true whether you like it or not.

I do believe that The Tatmadaw never ever want to do that. But, unfortunately they were pushed into the complicated game in the history. And then they do the politics like the way they live in their whole life. It is terrible.

Being a soldier's life is very simple. As everybody know that the ex-military persons are very hard to make relationship in the civilian life. But their thinking is very straight forward and they always have two options: YES or NO.

For being a politician's life is very tricky. They need to think everything at the same time and they may have many options: Yes, No or May be, etc....

In here, what I would like to highlight is that there are different situations between Soldiers and Politicians life. Not only Politician shouldn't behave like a soldier but also soldier shouldn't behave like a politician. Otherwise they will be lost in their game.

For us, we, the younger generation in Tatmadaw are not interesting in Politics and we just want to do our own jobs: Infantry soldiers would be trying to upgrade their stamina for the combat, the military medical personnel would be studying in their respective subjects. That is all we want to do, etc....Nothing more and nothing less.

But our leaders give us an order to do something, we must follow the order no matter what happen. I hope this kind of day will not be coming in the Future of our country.

KIND REGARDS,

THE ONE WHO IS REALLY PROUD HIMSELF IN SOLDIER'S LIFE

Than said...

တပ္မေတာ္သည္. . . . .. . .တိုင္းျပည္အတြက္
တိုင္းျပည္သည္. . . .. . . . .တပ္မေတာ္အတြက္မဟုတ္
စည္းကမ္းမရွိတဲ့ .. . .. . . . စစ္တပ္ရွိေနမဲ့အစား
အဲဒီစစ္တပ္မရွိတာ. .. . . . .တိုင္းျပည္အတြက္ . . . .. . .ပိုေကာင္းတယ္

ဗိုလ္ခ်ဳပ္ေအာင္ဆန္း

တိမ္ၾကားမင္းေခါင္ said...

စည္းကမ္းမရွိတဲ့တပ္မေတာ္ မရွိတာတိုင္းျပည္အတြက္ပိုေကာင္းတယ္ဆိုတဲ့အခ်က္ကုိရွင္းျပေပးပါအေပၚကပုဂၢိဳလ္။ဘယ္တပ္မေတာ္ကစည္းကမ္းမရွိတာလဲ။ဘယ္လိုစည္းကမ္းမရွိတာလဲ။တပ္မေတာ္ကဘာတာ၀န္ေတြပ်က္ကြက္ခဲ့လဲ။ျပီးေတာ့တပ္မေတာ္အေပၚကုိဘယ္သူေတြကတာ၀န္ေတြပ်က္ကြက္ခဲလဲ။တပ္မေတာ္လဲျပည္သူပါ။စစ္သားလဲျပည္သူပါပဲ။စစ္သားလဲလူပါပဲ။သူတို႕ေတြလခတစ္ပဲေျခာက္ျပားနဲ႕ဘာျဖစ္လို႕အေသခံလုပ္ေနက်တာလဲ။စဥ္းစားဖူးပါသလား။အက်င့္ပ်က္၀န္ထမ္းတစ္ခ်ဳိ႕ကုိပဲၾကည့္ျပီး တပ္မေတာ္တစ္ခုလံုးကုိမထိခိုက္ပါနဲ႕ဗ်ာ။ေသေသခ်ာခ်ာစဥ္းစားၾကည့္ဲၾကပါ။သိေအာင္လုပ္ပါ။တတ္ေအာင္သင္ပါ။ျပီးမွေ၀ဖန္ပါ။မွားတာရွိရင္ခြင့္လြတ္ပါ။လူဆိုတာအမွားနဲ႕မကင္းႏိုင္ပါဘူး

ေမာင္ေရႊရိုး said...

ဟီး...ဘာေျပာရမွန္းမသိေတာ႕ဘူး
အစိုးရသစ္ကိုေ၀ဖန္တဲ႕ေကာင္ေတြကိုဆဲခ်င္တာ ...
ဘာပဲေျပာေျပာေလ .. အခုဆို ကားေစ်းေတြက်ကုန္ျပီ။ေဒၚလာေစ်းေတာ႕ျပန္မတတ္ေစျခင္ဘူး....

တိမ္ၾကားမင္းေခါင္ said...

အေပၚကပုဂၢိဳလ္ကကၽြန္ေတာ့္ကိုဘာေၾကာင့္ဆဲတာလဲ။ေျပာစရာယဥ္ယဥ္ေက်းေက်းစကားလံုးေတြမရွိေတာ့ဘူးလား။ေလတပ္အေၾကာင္းမသိဘူးလားလို႕လို႕ေျပာရေအာင္ ခင္ဗ်ားကေကာဘယ္ေလာက္သိလို႕လဲ။ကၽြန္ေတာ္ေျပာတဲ့စကားတစ္ခြန္းရွိတယ္။သိေအာင္လုပ္။တတ္ေအာင္သင္လုိ႕ေျပာဘူးတယ္ေနာ္။သိေအာင္ၾကိဳးစားပါအံုးဗ်ာ။ခင္ဗ်ားမိုက္ရိုင္းတာ က မ်ဳိးရိုးကဆင္းသက္လာတာထင္တယ္ေနာ္။သတိထားအံုး။မ်ဳိးရိုးပါ မေကာင္းျဖစ္သြားမယ္။

Anonymous said...

(1) Tatmadaw ranks and files MUST understand and be interested in the politics and political process but NOT get involved in it while in uniform
(2) Tatmadaw MUST be the Pillar of Constitution and democracy while serving two main important tasks territorial integrity and sovereignty of Our Nation.
(3)Following the order Must also come with the sense of DUTY, Order itself Is NOT the key to follow but Sense of DUTY and Responsibility greater than that order and the person giving that order is the KEY. this is the only way Order-er gives the right judge order and Order-ee follows that order to the dot. VERY VERY IMPORTANT IN MILITARY. Otherwise non-sense orders from non-sense stupid leader (political or otherwise) will rack the country WHICH we server for.
Ordinaryman

Anonymous said...

Oh by the way Proud Soldier, NLD will not win a big time in 2015 or thereafter, party will dissipate after this by-election.

Anonymous said...

Dear my friend Ordinary man,

Thank you very much for your discussion. I totally understand your points which you want to highlight in here. Please let me explain you.

1. I agree with you that Thatmadaw should understand and interest in Political process.

2. And I realize that according to the situation of our Country, Thatmadaw is now the pillar of Constitution (2008).

3. What I understand in this point is that we should follow the right order which comes from the right leader. I partly agree in this point. I am going to explain to you.

This is a perfect concept and we will be very lucky when we always get the right order from the right leader. Unfortunately, we are living in the real World and this cannot be always fulfilled while we are in the field. We just make assumption that all of the orders are right and which is coming from the right person. I do know that this is unacceptable. But if you let the military to scrutinize every orders, this can be the worst for the country and they will be fighting each other in the near future. I would like to say that it is impossible.

But, here is the thing that we can do something better for this kind of situation. We should try to polish our promotion system to give the authority to the right one who is intelligent and has a good character. It is possible but many limitations.

And the last thing, there were some bad images in the history of our lovely Tatmadaw. This is not because of the soldiers who followed the order but just because of the system which chose the wrong one to lead the country. (SYSTEM ERROR)


KIND REGARDS,

Anonymous said...

Dear,

To be honest, I don't like NLD and I will not vote it in the election. But it doesn't mean that I want to demolish the party from the political field.

As we realized that we already had a big party in the 2010 election and which is USDP. Now our political system needs another big party to make counter balance to USPD otherwise we will return back to the previous situation: the only one party controlled everything in the country (1974-1988). In the other hand, USPD can also make counter balance to NLD. Therefor the country will be equilibrium in political situation.

Anyway, I think it is good for our country and our people but I am not sure that whether the politicians form USPD and NLD will like this kind of situation or not.

Regards,

The one who is really proud himself to be soldier

Anonymous said...

တပ္မေတာ္ကိုျဖိဳခြဲတာ ဘယ္သူမွမဟုတ္ပါဘူး...တပ္မေတာ္ၾကီးကိုခုတုန္းလုပ္ျပီး သိပ္ခ်မ္းသာသြားတဲ့ စစ္ဗိုလ္ခ်ဳပ္ၾကီးေတြပါပဲ...တပ္မေတာ္ထဲမွာ ေအပိုး-ဘီပိုး-စီပိုး-အိုင္ပိုး-အိုပိုး အလုပ္သင္ပိုး...စံုတကာ့စံုတဲ့ ညစ္ပတ္နည္းေတြနဲ႔ အရာရွိေတြကိုနည္းေပါင္းစံုနဲ႔ ျဖဳတ္ထုတ္လုပ္ခဲ့ျပီးပါျပီ...ဆက္လည္းလုပ္ေနဆဲပါ...အဲဒီလိုနည္းလမ္းေပါင္းစံုနဲ႔ခံခဲ့ရျပီး ဘ၀ပ်က္ေနတဲ့ စစ္တပ္ကအရာရွိေတြ အခု အျပင္မွာ အမ်ားၾကီးပါဗ်ာ...ေရးရမွာ ရင္နာလြန္းလ္ို႔ ...ဒီေလာက္နဲ႔ပဲေတာ္ေတာ့မယ္။

Anonymous said...

Perhaps you misunderstood the points proud soldier, (I'd like to call this to myself but I refrain myself doing so)I was not talking about ideal situation but I was talking about generic nature of quality judgement among soldiers(private to full colonel in field). Once you see enough you'd understand what I am talking about. Chains of Command shall never be broken but this is only as strong as its weakest link. Also it was not the system it was PEOPLE who rack the system and country. I wont comment system Vs people in length as it deserves a thesis level analysis and research!!! but anyway I did write here and there about myanmar tatmadaw leadership and hardship since 1998.
going back to the order-er and order-ee, system is to OBEY but PEOPLE carry out this concept. Once one side abuses this? think about it. If you are a platoon leader, you caught a rebel who surrendered, your company commander order you to kill all who surrendered. (forget about the hardship and some reality of jungle in this example)? well there are many things we need to do for Tatmadaw to become a pillar of our nation and beloved one by all citizens. One things for sure, to make sure our tatmadaw is well-disciplined and general education and training for all ranks is high. Most of all, these words are still in my heart" tatmadaw is the school where men can learn how to be the Best able man (Yautkyar kaung)". Are we all good enough to declare ourselves Yautkyar kaung? or how many percents of our Tatmadaw? nonetheless, we cannot have perfection in any organization but we cannot be lenient to any deviation from MAIN PRINCIPLES. that is where ORDERS MUST RESIDE.
ordinaryman

အျမင္မွန္ေစခ်င္သူ said...

အေပၚက..(တပ္မေတာ္ကိုျဖိဴခြဲတာဘယ္သူမွနဟုတ္ဘူး တပ္မေတာ္ကိုခုတံုးလုပ္ျပီးသိပ္ခ်မ္းသာသြားတဲ႕စစ္ဗိုယ္ခ်ဴပ္ေတြ)လို႕ေျပာတဲ႕အမည္မရွိသူခင္ဗ်ာ၊ မင္းေျပာတဲ႕စကားမွာတင္အေျဖပါျပီးသားကိုနီးရက္နဲ႕ေ၀းေနလို႕သတိေပးတာပါ။အဲ႕လိုခ်မ္းသာေအာင္ကိုယ္က်ိဴးရွာလို႕ျဖဴတ္ထုတ္ ခံရတာေပါ႕။ သူတို႕မေကာင္းလို႕သူတို႕ျပဴတ္တာဘ၀ပ်က္တာဘာဆန္းလဲ၊အမ်ားၾကီးရင္းႏွီးေပးဆပ္ျပိးျဖစ္လာတဲ႕ရာထူးကိုဘယ္သူမွအေၾကာင္းမရွိမျဖဴတ္ဘူး။ေနာက္တခုကမင္းေျပာတဲ႕ဘီ၊စီ၊ေအပိုးစတာေတြကလဲအဲ႕ပိုးရွိေနသူဟာတပ္မေတာ္ကေပးတဲ႕တာ၀န္ကိုဘယ္လိုမွမထမ္းေဆာင္ႏိုင္တာလူတိုင္းနားလည္ျပီးသားကို မင္းတေယာက္ထဲရူပ္ေနတာပါ။ အဲ႕ေရာဂါရွိသူေတြဟာအပငါပမ္းမခံႏိုင္တာေလာက္မင္းသိသင္႕တယ္၊ေအပိုးဘဲအပင္ပမ္းမခံႏိုင္တာပါလို႕လာမေျပာနဲ႕ေနာ္၊ဘီ၊စီ လဲဒီအတိုင္းဘဲဆရာ၀န္နဲ႕သာေမးေတာ႕။ဒီလိုေရာဂါပိုးရွိသူဟာၾကမ္းတမ္းတဲ႕စစ္သားဘ၀မေျပာနဲ႕ႏိုင္ငံတကာမွာေတာင္ေအ၊ဘီ၊စီ၊တီဘီပိုးစတာေတြစစ္ရတာအလုပ္ၾကမ္းသမားေရာ ၊အဲယားကြန္းနဲ႕ကြန္ျပဴတာေရွ႕မွာအလုပ္လုပ္တဲ႕သူေရာစစ္ရတယ္။အဲ႕ဒါဘာေၾကာင္႕လဲေတာ႕အဲ႕ႏိုင္ငံေတြသာသြားေမးေတာ႕၊မင္းသမၼတျဖစ္မွအဲ႕လိုေရာဂါပိုးရွိသူေတြစစ္တိုက္ခိုင္းဘို႕အဆိုတင္သြင္းေတာ႕..ဟုတ္ျပီလား၊ ႏိုင္ငံတကာမွာပါကန္႕ကြက္ကြာ..ဟုတ္ျပီလား။

Anonymous said...

ထြီ.........................................................................................................................ဟီ.......ဟီ...........

Anonymous said...

Nice blog here! Additionally your website a lot up very fast!
What web host are you the use of? Can I get your affiliate hyperlink for your host?
I desire my site loaded up as fast as yours lol

Here is my web page: Strasbourg Hotels

Post a Comment

မိတ္ေဆြတို ့၏ ေဆြးေႏြးမူ ေဝဖန္မူ အား လိူက္လွဲစြာ ၾကိဳဆိုပါသည္။
သင္တို႔၏ ေဝဖန္ အၾကံေပးမွူတို႔အား ေဖာ္ျပခြင့္ရရန္ ေခတၱ ေစာင့္ဆိုင္းပါ ။


သမၼတၾကီးဦးသိန္းစိန္၏ ဥေရာပျပန္ခရီးစဥ္အား ၾကိဳဆိုခဲ့ၾကပံုမ်ား

ဦးသိန္းစိန္ အားဤသို႔ၾကိဳဆိုခဲ့ၾက ၾကိဳဆိုသူမ်ားနဲ႔ အင္တာဗ်ဴး
တပ္မ၄၄+KNLAတပ္မ၁နဲ႔သရုပ္ေဆာင္တို႔ရဲ့ ျငိမ္းခ်မ္းေရးေဘာလံုးပြဲ ဝန္ၾကီးဦးေအာင္မင္းႏွင့္ေကအိုင္အိုျငိမ္းခ်မ္းေရးေဆြးေႏြးပြဲ
အံဖြယ္၃ႏွစ္ကေလးရဲ့ေမြးရာပါ ပါရမီ ျမန္မာ့သိုင္းအစြမ္း

Latest Videos

88 ေခါင္းေဆာင္ေတြ ဒီလိုနည္းနဲ့ေခါင္းေဆာင္ျဖစ္လာတယ္ ေျပာင္ၾကီးဘာလို့ေထာင္က်